by descent to the artist's granddaughter, Elizabeth Romney, Whitestock Hall, Ulverston (d. 1893); her estate sale, Christie's (London), 24 - 25 May 1894, any number of lots; Xavier Haas, Paris (1876-1936), variation of L.4541; his widow’s sale, Christie's (London), 12 July 1937, lot 36 (with D.1952.RW.2880, 2881, 2883 and 2884); purchased by Sir Robert Witt, London (1872-1952), L.2228b (on former mount, now missing) (10s, £3.13.6 for all 5); Witt Bequest 1952 Romney drawings 2875-2884 all passed through the Christie's 12 July 1937 sale, of Xavier Haas's widow (see the Lugt entry for L.4541), which had written above the lots "These Drawings came from the Sale of Romney's Studio in 1894, the contents of which had been most carefully preserved in the same house since the Artist's death in 1802". All of these Romney drawings are marked on their index cards as coming from the sale of Romney's studio in 1894, with their lot numbers. It appears these lot numbers came from old labels on the former mounts, all of which have since been removed and are now missing, with the exception of D.1952.RW.2877, which also records that this drawing was formerly in Colnaghi's collection. However, these lot numbers do not correspond to the lots in the actual catalogue, which is available online. A search of the 1894 catalogue also does not reveal that any of Witt's drawings are described as such in this sale, though there are several lots just described as 'Studies of Figures' or 'Studies for Pictures', in which these drawings could well have been included. The lot numbers on the Witt cards also do not correspond to those in Romney's 1807 estate sale or his son's 1834 estate sale. In the file for D.1952.RW.2875 is an index card which quotes W. Roberts as saying he examined an album with 250 photographs of Romney drawings, and he says he recognises all of them as coming from this 1894 sale, he says as mentioned by the late Mr Fairfax Murray, late Mr Martin Colnaghi, Mr C. Newton Robinson and Mr E. Duveen. In the annotated catalogue of the 1894 sale, of those names just listed, only Murray appears as a buyer of any drawings - of lots 128 ('Studies of Figures'), 129 ('Studies of heads and figures') and 200 (under 'Unfinished studies', 'Study for Titania'; and two landscapes, which could be D.1952.RW.2880). Colnaghi and Robinson appear on the index cards of some of these drawings as the former owners, so while it appears they were not buyers at the 1894 sale (unless through an intermediary), there must have been labels of some kind attesting to their former ownership, again likely on former mounts now missing, which, again, D.1952.RW.2877 attests to with the label on its extant mount. A further complication is that all of these Witt cards, although they bear clippings of the lots from the Christie's 1937 catalogue on their versos, are typed on the rectos as having been bought from Sotheby's. Troutman thought this meant Sotheby's acted as buyer for Witt at the Christie's sale, but in an annotated catalogue of the Christie's sale (in the Courtauld library) Witt's name is written as the buyer of lots 5, 19 and 36. It seems more likely, therefore, that while typing the index cards he merely forgot which auction house the clippings came from - an easy mistake to make.

Blunt, Anthony, Hand-list of the drawings in the Witt Collection, London, 1956
p. 42

Watermark: Recto, right centre edge, fragment: edge of a circle with a thin double border, abutted by small letter "B" (too fragmentary to identify).

Inscription: Verso: upper left corner, graphite: "266"; upper centre edge, graphite, mostly erased and illegible: "[...] 554 [?]"; upper centre, graphite: "Rosencrantz". Mount (removed, see photo), Recto: lower centre, brown ink: "P. ROMNEY".

Collector's mark: ? Mount (removed, recorded in a letter of 1961 in file), in a cartouche: "P. ROMNEY" [very similar to collector's mark of Xavier Haas, L.4541, but not the same]. Troutman's notes record that the mark of Sir Robert Witt (L.2228b) was also on this mount at lower right.